(c) Skyhound

I took this image of M46 and NGC 2438 with iTelescope T21 on the nights of February 9th and 10th. I'm pretty happy with it given that the total exposure time was only 15 minutes. This is a combination one five minute exposure in the Red filter, and one ten minute exposure in the Blue. I used SkyTools 3 to plan the observation. In addition to calculating the best times to expose, SkyTools helped me determine that I should expose twice as long in the blue filter than in the red to get a color balanced image. All processing was done in Photoshop. The green channel is a 50-50 combination of the red and blue. The color balance is entirely natural. No adjustments were made. Click on the image to see the full size version (look on the far left edge for the smaller M 1-18 planetary nebula). North is to the left and east is down.

The open cluster M46 is one of my all-time favorite objects to observe. The view of a small oval planetary nebula embedded in what Burnham's describes as a "fine circular cloud of small stars" always leaves me with a grin on my face. I saw M46 for the first time in college when a fellow student (who is now a PhD astronomer) showed it to me in a 21-inch telescope. It was breathtaking. 

By itself M46 is an excellent open cluster, particularly for telescopes under 12 inches (30 cm). It contains some 150 stars from 9th to 13th magnitude within a circle of 30'.  At a distance of 4500 light years, the stars are contained within a region 40 light years across. This cluster can be a bit difficult to find as it lies far from any bright constellation stars, and the nearby larger and brighter open cluster M47 can easily be mistaken for it. I always start from Sirius and look along a line to the east roughly in the opposite direction of Beta CMa. There is a ragged line of fainter stars, which I follow to about twice the distance between Sirius and Beta CMa. But I've been finding this thing most of my life. For those who haven't, a good finder chart will help a lot. 

The 10th magnitude planetary nebula NGC 2438 was first noticed by William Herschel in 1786. Small (1.1') and round, with some structure visible in larger instruments, NGC 2438 lies about 7' to the north of the cluster center. Look for a tiny hazy spot, as if one of the stars is out of focus. Once you spot it, try higher magnification. The planetary is located between us and the cluster of stars.

The Hidden Gem

Another planetary nebula lies a mere 30' north of the cluster. Minkowski 1-18 is small (30") and faint, and few people know about it. Without an OIII filter it is out of reach of even an 18-inch telescope under dark skies. But the OIII (and UHC) bring this planetary within reach of larger amateur instruments.  It's not clear what the minimum aperture required is to see it, but based on my observations I'd say that it should be detectable in a 14-inch (36 cm) scope, if not a 12 inch (30 cm). It should be a real treat for those with access to 20-inch or larger scopes.

I first observed this smaller gem in my 18-inch Dob way back in 2001. My log entry states: "With the OIII in place M 1-18 became readily apparent at 166x and just bright enough to sustain 430x with averted vision. It appeared round and very diffuse; no obvious structure was seen.  I had the impression at times of a fairly sharp, slightly ragged, edge. With the OIII removed I saw nothing.

Planning Your Observation

Note that we have made the window as small as possible to fit the space here.

The SkyTools 3 Nightly Planner is set up (above) for February 12 at Benson Arizona for an 8-inch (20 cm) Dobsonian telescope. The good old standard Messier observing list is loaded. M46 is selected. The red-dashed line in the graphic at the top displays the altitude of M46 during the night. The teal line is the altitude of the moon. The shading is the actual brightness of the sky taking into account moonlight, twilight, etc. Just by looking at the line we can see that the best time to observe M46 will be between 22:00 and 23:00. But how much effect will the moon have on it? In fact the moon is a waxing crescent and not all that bright. For observing the stars in M46, SkyTools has calculated that you can go ahead and start looking at 20:22 (the Begin column in the planner). The best view will be at 22:54, and the good views will last until 00:50, when it is low enough in the sky that we are looking through too much air, which dims the stars and blurs them due to atmospheric turbulence.

Click on the image below to see a full size printable finder chart (pdf) that was made by right-clicking on M46 in the planner. These charts are customized for the telescope and finding device to show the same stars you will see in the sky, finder, and eyepiece. 

The left side shows the naked-eye sky with Rigel QuikFinder circles at the location of M46. On the right is the view in a wide field eyepiece. The orientation and magnitude limits are calculated for the time and location, including light pollution, twilight, and moonlight.  

Greg Crinklaw — Developer of SkyTools 

SkyTools 3, because the astronomy matters.

Read more about SkyTools 3